How to Determine Which Level of Post HS Soccer Fits You Best

The journey toward playing soccer at the next level is a time-consuming endeavor filled with potential, ambition, and many questions. One of the most pressing questions young athletes and their families face is figuring out their next level. Are you a PRO, Division I, Division II, Division III, NAIA, or JUCO recruit? Understanding where you fit within these levels is crucial to not just achieving your athletic dreams but also ensuring a fulfilling college experience.

Before diving into self-assessment, it’s vital to grasp what each division offers. 

Going pro after high school soccer is the rarest route, but it does happen! In our national 2024 rankings, we have recorded 3 girls and 19 boys going pro directly following their high school career.

Division I schools are often characterized by their intense competitive environments and significant time commitments to sports. Only the top 1-2% of high school athletes earn a spot on a Division I team.

Division II balances athletics with academics a little more evenly, offering a competitive landscape but with more flexibility for student-athletes. Keep in mind though, Division II is extremely competitive as well, and the main difference between Division I and Division II is that there is less athletic scholarship money to offer for D2s.

Division III focuses primarily on the student experience, emphasizing participation and personal growth over athletic scholarships and competition. Division III athletics are still VERY high level. In fact, several Division III schools have beaten Division II schools in exhibition games in recent history.

NAIA is a non-NCAA division that mirrors that of Division II and Division III with top competition, and the ability to offer some athletic scholarships.

JUCO is a great level for many players, offering a launching pad to play at other divisions after 1 or 2 years. JUCOs give players the opportunity to complete general ed requirements and boost their academic standing.

Data from NCAA Study

Now that you have a general understanding of the various levels of college soccer, the key to accurately determining your fit lies in a comprehensive evaluation of your athletic skills, academic achievements, and personal preferences. This involves more than just self-reflection; it requires data, feedback, and a clear understanding of the college sports landscape. Below are 2 of the 3 KEYS revelead in our Recruiting Newsletter to help you determine your level

Start by exploring our exclusive College Coach Database. This tool allows you to search for programs based on various criteria, helping you match your athletic and academic profile with potential schools. The College Coach Database is available to premium and all-access subscribers only. Subscribe today to search AND gain contact information for schools at every level.

Our in-depth Prospect Rankings offer a unique perspective on where you stand among peers. By comparing your achievements and skills against others, you can better understand your potential division placement. What schools are recruiting players ranked near you? Where have players committed from your state in previous years at your rank?

Curious about our methodology? Read more about how we rank

Understanding which level fits you after high school is just the beginning. Our comprehensive monthly newsletter and recruiting resources delve deeper into each step of the recruiting process, providing you with the tools, strategies, and insights needed to navigate your recruitment journey confidently.

Don’t think you need the advice yet? The Recruiting Newsletter is specifically tailored to your year in the recruiting journey, offering different and relevant advice to Freshman, Sophomores, Juniors, and Seniors.

Subscribe below to gain full access to our expert guide and unlock the secrets to finding your perfect college athletic fit. Your path to college recruitment clarity and success starts here.